This time of year, many families spend quality time snuggling up and watching movies appropriate for the season. However, as my own children are growing (our oldest is 6) I am taking a second look at many popular movies that are branded "family friendly".
Home Alone
(1990)
Premise - The story of a young boy, Kevin McCallister, who is accidently left behind when his family leaves for Christmas vacation. At first, he's enchanted with his new found freedom (eating ice cream and watching movies that may give him nightmares are some of the indulgences he enjoys). However he soon learns that two bumbling burglars are planning to rob his house. He creatively sets up booby-traps to foil their plans. The police--and his parents--arrive in the nick of time, and Kevin realizes that he values being with his family more than perceived freedom.
Grade - C+
Rationale - While any child would revel in the fact that they're free to do as they please and then get to defend their domicile against burglers, the story glorifies characteristics that aren't noble. Kevin often talks back to his parents, he despises his siblings (who mistreat him at every instance) and has contempt for adults in general. There are a few instances of bad language, a reference to pornography, As an overall trend, it seems that from 1990 onward, many movies were made where children are the heros and adults are viewed as less intelligent, uncooperative, and, at times, villainous. Unfortunately, this movie does so as well.
How the Grinch Stole Christmas
(2000)
Premise - The original Seuss cartoon is not in-depth or reflective on Christ as the meaning of Christmas in any way (nor was it written to be, which isn't necessarily a bad thing). This version had an uncaring Grinch who was selfish and mean. He wants to steal Christmas because of the Who's loud noise and singing. He hopes to rob them of their Christmas and takes their gifts, decor and food. However, although he takes the tangibles of Christmas, it still comes, just the same. He learns that Christmas is more than presents and food. His heart then grows three sizes larger, returns all of the stolen goods, and joins the Who's for roast-beast dinner.
This remake is a big budget film with Jim Carey starring as the Grinch. This rendition paints the Grinch as a boy who grew up in Whoville, and was teased incessantly for being different. He tried to live a "normal" life amongst the Whos, however they teased and tormented him so much that he flees the town and lives a secluded life in the mountains. When a small Who knocks on his door and invites him back to town, he has a chance to re-join society. He does so, and is laughed out of town. Thus he hatches a plan to steal Christmas--a day that the Whos love more than anything. At first, the Whos are miserable. Then, a townsmen reminds the mayor that Christmas is about Spirit--something the Grinch could not steal! They ascend upon the Grinch's cave and partake in Christmas dinner with him, with the Grinch carving the roast-beast.
Grade - D
Rationale - The story is old, tried, and not lasting. As an added bonus, interwoven throughout the thin story, are costumes that are not appropriate, sexual connotations, implied illicit encounters, and a Christmas that focuses on food, decor, and gifts--and past girlfriends! Check out Steve Greydanus'
funny and right-on review at decentfilms.com.
Stay tuned for a few Christmas movie recommendations not to pass up!